Abo Bibliothek: Guest
Critical Reviews™ in Biomedical Engineering

Erscheint 6 Ausgaben pro Jahr

ISSN Druckformat: 0278-940X

ISSN Online: 1943-619X

SJR: 0.262 SNIP: 0.372 CiteScore™:: 2.2 H-Index: 56

Indexed in

Genetic Testing of the General Population: Ethical and Informatic Concerns

Volumen 28, Ausgabe 3&4, 2000, pp. 557-561
DOI: 10.1615/CritRevBiomedEng.v28.i34.360
Get accessGet access

ABSTRAKT

Whether we like it or not, genetic testing will almost certainly become routine medical practice within the next 25 years. Integrated circuit chips already exist that can perform 400 genetic tests simultaneously, thus greatly reducing the costs. At least one company is already working on a prototype for a handheld genetic tester that would allow primary care physicians to perform hundreds or thousands of genetic tests on a simple blood smear in just a few minutes. "Genetic report cards" for children are not very far off at all.
The use of such widespread testing poses a variety of ethical dilemmas. One problem that has not been appreciated sufficiently, however, is the question of how to interpret the test results. Because of the way s the genes implicated in diseases are discovered and marketed, quantitative analysis of the tests can be extremely misleading. The difficulty is that we simply do not have sufficient information about variance in genetic and other factors in the general population to make accurate projections of a patient's risk, given the presence of a gene. This uncertainty is obscured, however, when we provide the patient with a numerical analysis of risk because it is well established that people tend to overestimate the information content of numerical projections. This situation is made far worse by the fact that we do not have enough adequately trained genetic counselors to handle the load that will soon be placed on them (and studies have shown that physicians are generally very poorly prepared to act as accurate sources of information on complex genetic issues).
For these reasons, I argue that access to genetic testing should be treated the same way as access to new medical procedures and medications — namely, withheld from the general public until proven safe and effective in large-scale trials. This is certain to be an unpopular policy, but it seems the only way to prevent a great deal of abuse of genetic tests.

REFERENZIERT VON
  1. Bookman Ebony B., Langehorne Aleisha A., Eckfeldt John H., Glass Kathleen C., Jarvik Gail P., Klag Michael, Koski Greg, Motulsky Arno, Wilfond Benjamin, Manolio Teri A., Fabsitz Richard R., Luepker Russell V., Reporting genetic results in research studies: Summary and recommendations of an NHLBI working group, American Journal of Medical Genetics Part A, 140A, 10, 2006. Crossref

  2. Bookman Ebony B, Din-Lovinescu Corina, Worrall Bradford B, Manolio Teri A, Bennett Siiri N, Laurie Cathy, Mirel Daniel B, Doheny Kimberly F, Anderson Garnet L, Wehr Kate, Weinshilboum Richard, Chen Donna T, Incidental genetic findings in randomized clinical trials: recommendations from the Genomics and Randomized Trials Network (GARNET), Genome Medicine, 5, 1, 2013. Crossref

  3. Stemerding Dirk, Swierstra Tsjalling, Boenink Marianne, Exploring the interaction between technology and morality in the field of genetic susceptibility testing: A scenario study, Futures, 42, 10, 2010. Crossref

  4. Godard Béatrice, ten Kate Leo, Evers-Kiebooms Gerry, Aymé Ségolène, Population genetic screening programmes: principles, techniques, practices, and policies, European Journal of Human Genetics, 11, S2, 2003. Crossref

  5. Manolio Teri A., Taking Our Obligations to Research Participants Seriously: Disclosing Individual Results of Genetic Research, The American Journal of Bioethics, 6, 6, 2006. Crossref

  6. Wu¨stner Kerstin, Ethics and practice: Two worlds? The example of genetic counselling, New Genetics and Society, 22, 1, 2003. Crossref

Digitales Portal Digitale Bibliothek eBooks Zeitschriften Referenzen und Berichte Forschungssammlungen Preise und Aborichtlinien Begell House Kontakt Language English 中文 Русский Português German French Spain