ISSN Druckformat: 2151-805X
ISSN Online: 2151-8068
Cutting Eugenics Out of CRISPR-Cas9
ABSTRAKT
The use of clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR) and their associated (Cas) proteins (the CRISPR-Cas system) in genomic engineering is among the most promising biomedical innovations to occur in the last few decades. One of this system's most profound features is its ability to edit genomes with impressive specificity, which may cause significant alterations of cellular, tissue, and organismal phenotypes at the near instance of the editing, over the lifespan of the organism and potentially into any number of future generations. We argue that the use of the CRISPR-Cas9 system to edit the human germline should be legally prohibited on account of the system's potential for generating an unjust eugenic future. Its use in nongermline experimentation and applications, however, should not be constrained on eugenic grounds. Such a blanket legal prohibition might limit the progress gleaned from this technology. Allowing experimentation in human subjects more broadly might expose participants to considerable risk and potentially harmful outcomes, and the system might prove unable to realize tangible therapeutic outcomes that seem likely ex ante. We conclude that the uncertainty inherent in CRISPR use should not lead to reflexive, preemptive prohibitions, but instead to ethical, fastidious, and controlled experimentation.
-
Cavaliere Giulia, Genome editing and assisted reproduction: curing embryos, society or prospective parents?, Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 21, 2, 2018. Crossref
-
Cavaliere Giulia, A Path Through the (Moral) Morass, in Between Moral Hazard and Legal Uncertainty, 2018. Crossref
-
Seeman Mary V, Women who suffer from schizophrenia: Critical issues, World Journal of Psychiatry, 8, 5, 2018. Crossref
-
Cavaliere Giulia, Looking into the shadow: the eugenics argument in debates on reproductive technologies and practices, Monash Bioethics Review, 36, 1-4, 2018. Crossref
-
Ranisch Robert, ‘Eugenics is Back’? Historic References in Current Discussions of Germline Gene Editing, NanoEthics, 13, 3, 2019. Crossref
-
Piergentili Roberto, Del Rio Alessandro, Signore Fabrizio, Umani Ronchi Federica, Marinelli Enrico, Zaami Simona, CRISPR-Cas and Its Wide-Ranging Applications: From Human Genome Editing to Environmental Implications, Technical Limitations, Hazards and Bioethical Issues, Cells, 10, 5, 2021. Crossref
-
Seiter Katie M., Fuselier Linda, Content knowledge and social factors influence student moral reasoning about CRISPR /Cas9 in humans , Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 58, 6, 2021. Crossref
-
Hussain Yaseen, Khan Haroon, Ahmad Imad, Efferth Thomas, Alam Waqas, Nanoscale delivery of phytochemicals targeting CRISPR/Cas9 for cancer therapy, Phytomedicine, 94, 2022. Crossref