Suscripción a Biblioteca: Guest
Portal Digitalde Biblioteca Digital eLibros Revistas Referencias y Libros de Ponencias Colecciones
Critical Reviews™ in Immunology
Factor de Impacto: 1.404 Factor de Impacto de 5 años: 3.347 SJR: 0.706 SNIP: 0.55 CiteScore™: 2.19

ISSN Imprimir: 1040-8401
ISSN En Línea: 2162-6472

Volumen 40, 2020 Volumen 39, 2019 Volumen 38, 2018 Volumen 37, 2017 Volumen 36, 2016 Volumen 35, 2015 Volumen 34, 2014 Volumen 33, 2013 Volumen 32, 2012 Volumen 31, 2011 Volumen 30, 2010 Volumen 29, 2009 Volumen 28, 2008 Volumen 27, 2007 Volumen 26, 2006 Volumen 25, 2005 Volumen 24, 2004 Volumen 23, 2003 Volumen 22, 2002 Volumen 21, 2001 Volumen 20, 2000 Volumen 19, 1999 Volumen 18, 1998 Volumen 17, 1997 Volumen 16, 1996 Volumen 15, 1995 Volumen 14, 1994

Critical Reviews™ in Immunology

DOI: 10.1615/CritRevImmunol.v19.i5-6.60
31 pages

Hard Science Versus Phenomenology in Reproductive Immunology

David A. Clark
Departments of Medicine, Pathology, Obstetrics and Gynecology, McMaster University, Room 3V39, 1200 Main Street West, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada L8N 3Z5


It has been suggested that studies of immunological aspects of reproduction have recently changed from the phenomenological (e.g., speculative/descriptive) to hard science (e.g., precise molecular description/explanation). The significance of this development is explored by analysis of the contribution made by hard science that has led to a number of assertions. Does HLA-G determine maternal tolerance of her semi-allogeneic fetus? Do differences in placentation between humans, rodents, and other species make direct comparisons largely meaningless? Does membrane cofactor protein (CD46) contribute to pregnancy success by protecting sperm and fetal trophoblast from complement-mediated lysis? Does a low frequency in mice of maternal T cells specific for paternal alloantigens occur, and if so, does phenomenon explain specific maternal tolerance in pregnancy? Do placental and decidual macrophage components provide an important immediate antigen-nonspecific host defense to infection? Does the mix of bioactive molecules make the uterus an immunologically privileged site, and does the molecular melange have a pivotal role in promoting growth and development of the placenta and embryo? Does prolactin acting on receptors on lymphocytes suppress function and thereby account for remission of autoimmune disease in pregnant women? Is the efficacy and safety of immunotherapy for recurrent spontaneous abortion a thorny issue that will be resolved by an ongoing funded national trial? What is a scientifically correct timeline of important discoveries and developments in reproductive immunology? It is argued that it is unprofitable to divorce phenomenology from hard science and that the timeline for developments in reproductive immunology begin with Darwin. Irrespective of whether one is dealing with phenomena or hard science data, Hippocrates was correct in his aphorism that "description is infinite and easy; explanation is limited and difficult".

Articles with similar content:

Dendritic Cell Tumor Killing Activity and Its Potential Applications in Cancer Immunotherapy
Critical Reviews™ in Immunology, Vol.33, 2013, issue 1
Neale Hanke, Darya Alizadeh, Nicolas Larmonier, Emmanuel Katsanis
Regulation of Lymphoid Cell Apoptosis by Jaks and Stats
Critical Reviews™ in Immunology, Vol.24, 2004, issue 2
Zsuzsanna S. Nagy, Jeremy Ross, Robert A. Kirken, Stanislaw M. Stepkowski, Hanyin Cheng
The Fetus and the Maternal Immune System: Pregnancy as a Model to Study Peripheral T-Cell Tolerance
Critical Reviews™ in Immunology, Vol.19, 1999, issue 5-6
Shi-Ping Jiang, Melanie S. Vacchio
Journal of Women and Minorities in Science and Engineering, Vol.9, 2003, issue 3&4
Beverley A. P. Taylor, Laura McCullough, Barbara L. Whitten, Margaret L. Duncombe, Paula Heron, Suzanne R. Foster, Patricia E. Allen, Heather M. Zorn, Kimberly A. Shaw
CD8 T Cells and Aging
Critical Reviews™ in Immunology, Vol.23, 2003, issue 1-2
Rita B. Effros, Phyllis-Jean Linton, Zeling Cai