年間 6 号発行
ISSN 印刷: 0278-940X
ISSN オンライン: 1943-619X
Indexed in
Inverse Optimization: Functional and Physiological Considerations Related to the Force-Sharing Problem
要約
This paper is a review of the optimization techniques used for the solution of the force-sharing problem in biomechanics; that is, the distribution of the net joint moment to the force generating structures such as muscles and ligaments. The solution to this problem is achieved by the minimization (or maximization) of an objective function that includes the design variables (usually muscle forces) that are subject to certain constraints, and it is generally related to physiological or mechanical properties such as muscle stress, maximum force or moment, activation level, etc. The usual constraints require the sum of the exerted moments to be equal to the net joint moment and certain boundary conditions restrict the force solutions within physiologically acceptable limits. Linear optimization (objective and constraint functions are both linear relationships) has limited capabilities for the solution of the force sharing problem, although the use of appropriate constraints and physiologically realistic boundary conditions can improve the solution and lead to reasonable and functionally acceptable muscle force predictions. Nonlinear optimization provides more physiologically acceptable results, especially when the criteria used are related to the dynamics of the movement (e.g., instantaneous maximum force derived from muscle modeling based on length and velocity histories). The evaluation of predicted forces can be performed using direct measurements of forces (usually in animals), relationship with EMG patterns, comparisons with forces obtained from optimized forward dynamics, and by evaluating the results using analytical solutions of the optimal problem to highlight muscle synergism for example. Global objective functions are more restricting compared to local ones that are related to the specific objective of the movement at its different phases (e.g., maximize speed or minimize pain). In complex dynamic activities multiobjective optimization is likely to produce more realistic results.
-
Carroll Andrew M., Wainwright Peter C., Muscle function and power output during suction feeding in largemouth bass, Micropterus salmoides, Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology Part A: Molecular & Integrative Physiology, 143, 3, 2006. Crossref
-
Xu Y., Terekhov A. V., Latash M. L., Zatsiorsky V. M., Forces and moments generated by the human arm: variability and control, Experimental Brain Research, 223, 2, 2012. Crossref
-
NIKOOYAN ALI A., VEEGER HEJ, WESTERHOFF PETER, BERGMANN GEORG, VAN DER HELM FRANS C. T., RELATIVE CONTRIBUTION OF DIFFERENT MUSCLE ENERGY CONSUMPTION PROCESSES IN AN ENERGY-BASED MUSCLE LOAD SHARING COST FUNCTION, Journal of Mechanics in Medicine and Biology, 13, 01, 2013. Crossref
-
Raikova Rositsa T., INVESTIGATION OF THE INFLUENCE OF THE ELBOW JOINT REACTION ON THE PREDICTED MUSCLE FORCES USING DIFFERENT OPTIMIZATION FUNCTIONS, Journal of Musculoskeletal Research, 12, 01, 2009. Crossref
-
Qin Jin, Chen Hua, Dennerlein Jack T., Wrist posture affects hand and forearm muscle stress during tapping, Applied Ergonomics, 44, 6, 2013. Crossref
-
Arslan Yunus Ziya, Kaya Motoshi, Herzog Walter, Evaluation of muscle force predictions using optimization theory, Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 410, 2013. Crossref
-
Vignais Nicolas, Marin Frédéric, Analysis of the musculoskeletal system of the hand and forearm during a cylinder grasping task, International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 44, 4, 2014. Crossref
-
Cantergi Débora, Loss Jefferson Fagundes, Jinha Azim, Brodt Guilherme Auler, Herzog Walter, Muscle strategies for leg extensions on a “Reformer” apparatus, Journal of Electromyography and Kinesiology, 25, 2, 2015. Crossref
-
Park Jaebum, Zatsiorsky Vladimir M., Latash Mark L., Optimality vs. variability: an example of multi-finger redundant tasks, Experimental Brain Research, 207, 1-2, 2010. Crossref
-
Terekhov Alexander V., Pesin Yakov B., Niu Xun, Latash Mark L., Zatsiorsky Vladimir M., An analytical approach to the problem of inverse optimization with additive objective functions: an application to human prehension, Journal of Mathematical Biology, 61, 3, 2010. Crossref
-
Niu Xun, Latash Mark L., Zatsiorsky Vladimir M., Effects of grasping force magnitude on the coordination of digit forces in multi-finger prehension, Experimental Brain Research, 194, 1, 2009. Crossref
-
Terekhov Alexander V., Zatsiorsky Vladimir M., Analytical and numerical analysis of inverse optimization problems: conditions of uniqueness and computational methods, Biological Cybernetics, 104, 1-2, 2011. Crossref
-
Cadova Michala, Vilimek Miloslav, Daniel Matej, A comparative study of muscle force estimates using Huxley's and Hill's muscle model, Computer Methods in Biomechanics and Biomedical Engineering, 17, 4, 2014. Crossref
-
Wit Andrzej, Czaplicki Adam, Inverse Dynamics and Artificial Neural Network Applications in Gait Analysis of the Disabled Subjects, Human Movement, 9, 2, 2008. Crossref
-
Steenbrink Frans, Meskers Carel G. M., van Vliet Bart, Slaman Jorrit, Veeger H. E. J., De Groot Jurriaan H., Arm load magnitude affects selective shoulder muscle activation, Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing, 47, 5, 2009. Crossref
-
Blajer Wojciech, Czaplicki Adam, Dziewiecki Krzysztof, Mazur Zenon, Influence of selected modeling and computational issues on muscle force estimates, Multibody System Dynamics, 24, 4, 2010. Crossref
-
Tagliabue Michele, Pedrocchi Alessandra, Pozzo Thierry, Ferrigno Giancarlo, A mathematical tool to generate complex whole body motor tasks and test hypotheses on underlying motor planning, Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing, 46, 1, 2008. Crossref
-
Jinha A., Ait-Haddou R., Binding P., Herzog W., Antagonistic activity of one-joint muscles in three-dimensions using non-linear optimisation, Mathematical Biosciences, 202, 1, 2006. Crossref
-
Naderi D., Pasha Zanoosi A.A., Sadeghi-Mehr M., Forward dynamics simulation of human body under tilting perturbations, Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation, 17, 2, 2012. Crossref
-
Magermans D.J., Chadwick E.K.J., Veeger H.E.J., van der Helm F.C.T., Rozing P.M., Biomechanical analysis of tendon transfers for massive rotator cuff tears, Clinical Biomechanics, 19, 4, 2004. Crossref
-
Forster E., Simon U., Augat P., Claes L., Extension of a state-of-the-art optimization criterion to predict co-contraction, Journal of Biomechanics, 37, 4, 2004. Crossref
-
Praagman M., Chadwick E.K.J., van der Helm F.C.T., Veeger H.E.J., The relationship between two different mechanical cost functions and muscle oxygen consumption, Journal of Biomechanics, 39, 4, 2006. Crossref
-
Menegaldo Luciano Luporini, Fleury Agenor de Toledo, Weber Hans Ingo, A ‘cheap’ optimal control approach to estimate muscle forces in musculoskeletal systems, Journal of Biomechanics, 39, 10, 2006. Crossref
-
Raikova Rositsa T, Aladjov Hristo Ts, Hierarchical genetic algorithm versus static optimization—investigation of elbow flexion and extension movements, Journal of Biomechanics, 35, 8, 2002. Crossref
-
Praagman M., Veeger H.E.J., Chadwick E.K.J., Colier W.N.J.M., van der Helm F.C.T., Muscle oxygen consumption, determined by NIRS, in relation to external force and EMG, Journal of Biomechanics, 36, 7, 2003. Crossref
-
Ghafari Ali Selk, Meghdari Ali, Vossoughi Gholam Reza, The effect of load carrying on the human lower extremity muscle activation during walking, 2008 5th International Symposium on Mechatronics and Its Applications, 2008. Crossref
-
Bonnefoy A., Robert T., Dumas R., Cheze L., Méthodes biomécaniques avancées pour le calcul des moments articulaires et des forces musculaires, IRBM, 29, 4, 2008. Crossref
-
Jinha Azim, Ait-Haddou Rachid, Herzog Walter, Predictions of co-contraction depend critically on degrees-of-freedom in the musculoskeletal model, Journal of Biomechanics, 39, 6, 2006. Crossref
-
Blana Dimitra, Hincapie Juan G., Chadwick Edward K., Kirsch Robert F., A musculoskeletal model of the upper extremity for use in the development of neuroprosthetic systems, Journal of Biomechanics, 41, 8, 2008. Crossref
-
Stansfield B.W., Nicol A.C., Paul J.P., Kelly I.G., Graichen F., Bergmann G., Direct comparison of calculated hip joint contact forces with those measured using instrumented implants. An evaluation of a three-dimensional mathematical model of the lower limb, Journal of Biomechanics, 36, 7, 2003. Crossref
-
Niu Xun, Latash Mark L., Zatsiorsky Vladimir M., Reproducibility and Variability of the Cost Functions Reconstructed From Experimental Recordings in Multifinger Prehension, Journal of Motor Behavior, 44, 2, 2012. Crossref
-
Erdemir Ahmet, McLean Scott, Herzog Walter, van den Bogert Antonie J., Model-based estimation of muscle forces exerted during movements, Clinical Biomechanics, 22, 2, 2007. Crossref
-
Stops Adam, Wilcox Ruth, Jin Zhongmin, Computational modelling of the natural hip: a review of finite element and multibody simulations, Computer Methods in Biomechanics and Biomedical Engineering, 15, 9, 2012. Crossref
-
David Ingram, Philippe Mullhaupt, Alexandre Terrier, Pralong Etienne, Farron Alain, Dynamical biomechanical model of the shoulder for muscle-force estimation, 2012 4th IEEE RAS & EMBS International Conference on Biomedical Robotics and Biomechatronics (BioRob), 2012. Crossref
-
Kristan Ane, Mavcic Bla, Cimerman Matej, Iglic Ale, Tonin Martin, Slivnik Toma, Kralj-Iglic Veronika, Daniel Matej, Acetabular Loading in Active Abduction, IEEE Transactions on Neural Systems and Rehabilitation Engineering, 15, 2, 2007. Crossref
-
Ait-Haddou R., Jinha A., Herzog W., Binding P., Analysis of the force-sharing problem using an optimization model, Mathematical Biosciences, 191, 2, 2004. Crossref
-
Stansfield B.W, Nicol A.C, Hip joint contact forces in normal subjects and subjects with total hip prostheses: walking and stair and ramp negotiation, Clinical Biomechanics, 17, 2, 2002. Crossref
-
Florio C. S., Development and implementation of a coupled computational muscle force optimization bone shape adaptation modeling method, International Journal for Numerical Methods in Biomedical Engineering, 31, 4, 2015. Crossref
-
Alonso J., Romero F., Pàmies-Vilà R., Lugrís U., Font-Llagunes J. M., A simple approach to estimate muscle forces and orthosis actuation in powered assisted walking of spinal cord-injured subjects, Multibody System Dynamics, 28, 1-2, 2012. Crossref
-
Cleather Daniel J., Bull Anthony M. J., An Optimization-Based Simultaneous Approach to the Determination of Muscular, Ligamentous, and Joint Contact Forces Provides Insight into Musculoligamentous Interaction, Annals of Biomedical Engineering, 39, 7, 2011. Crossref
-
Raikova R.T., Aladjov H.Ts., Comparison between two muscle models under dynamic conditions, Computers in Biology and Medicine, 35, 5, 2005. Crossref
-
Daniel Matej, Role of optimization criterion in static asymmetric analysis of lumbar spine load, Wiener Medizinische Wochenschrift, 161, 19-20, 2011. Crossref
-
Raikova R., About weight factors in the non-linear objective functions used for solving indeterminate problems in biomechanics, Journal of Biomechanics, 32, 7, 1999. Crossref
-
Jinha A., Ait-Haddou R., Kaya M., Herzog W., A task-specific validation of homogeneous non-linear optimisation approaches, Journal of Theoretical Biology, 259, 4, 2009. Crossref
-
Maganaris Constantinos N., Baltzopoulos Vasilios, Sargeant Anthony J., Human calf muscle responses during repeated isometric plantarflexions, Journal of Biomechanics, 39, 7, 2006. Crossref
-
McNitt-Gray J.L., Hester D.M.E., Mathiyakom W., Munkasy B.A., Mechanical demand and multijoint control during landing depend on orientation of the body segments relative to the reaction force, Journal of Biomechanics, 34, 11, 2001. Crossref
-
Fowler N.K., Nicol A.C., Interphalangeal joint and tendon forces: normal model and biomechanical consequences of surgical reconstruction, Journal of Biomechanics, 33, 9, 2000. Crossref
-
Modenese Luca, Phillips Andrew T. M., Prediction of hip contact forces and muscle activations during walking at different speeds, Multibody System Dynamics, 28, 1-2, 2012. Crossref
-
Rodrigo Silvia E., Ambrósio Jorge A. C., Tavares da Silva Miguel P., Penisi Osvaldo H., Analysis of Human Gait Based on Multibody Formulations and Optimization Tools#, Mechanics Based Design of Structures and Machines, 36, 4, 2008. Crossref
-
Praagman M., Chadwick E.K.J., van der Helm F.C.T., Veeger H.E.J., The effect of elbow angle and external moment on load sharing of elbow muscles, Journal of Electromyography and Kinesiology, 20, 5, 2010. Crossref
-
RAIKOVA ROSITSA, Investigation of the Peculiarities of Two-joint Muscles Using a 3 DOF Model of the Human Upper Limb in the Sagittal Plane: an Optimization Approach, Computer Methods in Biomechanics and Biomedical Engineering, 4, 6, 2001. Crossref
-
Kuo Mei-Ying, Tsai Tsung-Yuan, Lin Cheng-Chung, Lu Tung-Wu, Hsu Horng-Chaung, Shen Wu-Chung, Influence of soft tissue artifacts on the calculated kinematics and kinetics of total knee replacements during sit-to-stand, Gait & Posture, 33, 3, 2011. Crossref
-
Biscarini Andrea, Botti Fabio M., Pettorossi Vito E., Joint Torques and Joint Reaction Forces During Squatting With a Forward or Backward Inclined Smith Machine, Journal of Applied Biomechanics, 29, 1, 2013. Crossref
-
Lutz Frederick, Mastel Roland, Runge Martin, Stief Felix, Schmidt André, Meurer Andrea, Witte Hartmut, Calculation of muscle forces during normal gait under consideration of femoral bending moments, Medical Engineering & Physics, 38, 9, 2016. Crossref
-
Raikova Rositsa T., Some Mechanical Considerations on Muscle Coordination, Motor Control, 4, 1, 2000. Crossref
-
Marková Michala, Gallo Luigi M., The influence of the human TMJ eminence inclination on predicted masticatory muscle forces, Human Movement Science, 49, 2016. Crossref
-
Cruz Ruiz A.L., Pontonnier C., Pronost N., Dumont G., Muscle-Based Control for Character Animation, Computer Graphics Forum, 36, 6, 2017. Crossref
-
Sharifi Mojtaba, Pourtakdoust Seid H., Parnianpour Mohamad, Optimal control of human-like musculoskeletal arm: Prediction of trajectory and muscle forces, Optimal Control Applications and Methods, 38, 2, 2017. Crossref
-
Honarvar Sarah, Ehsani Hossein, Rostami Mostafa, Developing a hybrid method for solving optimal control problems of the musculoskeletal system of the human body: Combination of linear and angular actuators, 2015 2nd International Conference on Knowledge-Based Engineering and Innovation (KBEI), 2015. Crossref
-
ARSLAN YUNUS ZIYA, JINHA AZIM, KAYA MOTOSHI, HERZOG WALTER, PREDICTION OF MUSCLE FORCES USING STATIC OPTIMIZATION FOR DIFFERENT CONTRACTILE CONDITIONS, Journal of Mechanics in Medicine and Biology, 13, 03, 2013. Crossref
-
Bouillard Killian, Jubeau Marc, Nordez Antoine, Hug François, Effect of vastus lateralis fatigue on load sharing between quadriceps femoris muscles during isometric knee extensions, Journal of Neurophysiology, 111, 4, 2014. Crossref
-
Lin Yi-Chung, Dorn Tim W, Schache Anthony G, Pandy Marcus G, Comparison of different methods for estimating muscle forces in human movement, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part H: Journal of Engineering in Medicine, 226, 2, 2012. Crossref
-
Holmberg L J, Lund A M, A musculoskeletal full-body simulation of cross-country skiing, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part P: Journal of Sports Engineering and Technology, 222, 1, 2008. Crossref
-
Cleather Daniel J, Bull Anthony MJ, The development of lower limb musculoskeletal models with clinical relevance is dependent upon the fidelity of the mathematical description of the lower limb. Part 1: equations of motion, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part H: Journal of Engineering in Medicine, 226, 2, 2012. Crossref
-
Florio Catherine S, Narh Kwabena A, Development of a modeling technique for the investigation of muscle activity and its effect on bone stresses in the human leg during an isometric exercise, SIMULATION, 87, 4, 2011. Crossref
-
Daniel Matej, Tomanová Michaela, Hornová Jana, Novotná Iva, Lhotská Lenka, Biomechanical analysis of INFINITY rehabilitation method for treatment of low back pain, Journal of Physical Therapy Science, 29, 5, 2017. Crossref
-
Ardakani Fateme Fotouhi, Vatankhah Ramin, Sharifi Mojtaba, Fuzzy sliding-mode control of a human arm in the sagittal plane with optimal trajectory, ETRI Journal, 40, 5, 2018. Crossref
-
Dupré Thomas, Dietzsch Mareike, Komnik Igor, Potthast Wolfgang, David Sina, Agreement of measured and calculated muscle activity during highly dynamic movements modelled with a spherical knee joint, Journal of Biomechanics, 84, 2019. Crossref
-
Cohn Brian A., Szedlák May, Gärtner Bernd, Valero-Cuevas Francisco J., Feasibility Theory Reconciles and Informs Alternative Approaches to Neuromuscular Control, Frontiers in Computational Neuroscience, 12, 2018. Crossref
-
Daniel Matej, Debevec H., Kristan A., Mavcic B., Cimerman Matej, Tonin M., Acetabular forces and contact stresses in active abduction rehabilitation, in 11th Mediterranean Conference on Medical and Biomedical Engineering and Computing 2007, 16, 2007. Crossref
-
Ambrósio Jorge A. C., Kecskeméthy Andrés, Multibody Dynamics of Biomechanical Models for Human Motion via Optimization, in Multibody Dynamics, 4, 2007. Crossref
-
Sharifi Mojtaba, Salarieh Hassan, Behzadipour Saeed, Nonlinear Optimal Control of Planar Musculoskeletal Arm Model With Minimum Muscles Stress Criterion, Journal of Computational and Nonlinear Dynamics, 12, 1, 2017. Crossref
-
Jorge A.C. Ambrósio, Silva Miguel P.T., A Biomechanical Multibody Model with a Detailed Locomotion Muscle Apparatus, in Advances in Computational Multibody Systems, 2, 2005. Crossref
-
Paley Dror, Dynamic Deformities and Lever Arm Considerations, in Principles of Deformity Correction, 2002. Crossref
-
Ackermann Marko, Schiehlen Werner, Physiological Methods to Solve the Force-Sharing Problem in Biomechanics, in Multibody Dynamics, 12, 2008. Crossref
-
Ambrosio Jorge A. C., Multibody Dynamics Approaches to Biomechanical Applications to Human Motion Tasks, in Multibody System Dynamics, Robotics and Control, 2013. Crossref
-
Ambrósio Jorge A. C., Abrantes João M. C. S., Developments in Biomechanics of Human Motion for Health and Sports, in A Portrait of State-of-the-Art Research at the Technical University of Lisbon, 2007. Crossref
-
RAIKOVA ROSITSA, Prediction of Individual Muscle Forces Using Lagrange Multipliers Method — A Model of the Upper Human Limb in the Sagittal Plane: I. Theoretical Considerations, Computer Methods in Biomechanics and Biomedical Engineering, 3, 2, 2000. Crossref
-
Ezati Mahdokht, Ghannadi Borna, McPhee John, A review of simulation methods for human movement dynamics with emphasis on gait, Multibody System Dynamics, 47, 3, 2019. Crossref
-
Raikova Rositsa, Aladjov Hristo, The Influence of the Way the Muscle Force is Modeled on the Predicted Results Obtained by Solving Indeterminate Problems for a Fast Elbow Flexion, Computer Methods in Biomechanics and Biomedical Engineering, 6, 3, 2003. Crossref
-
Ambrósio Jorge A.C., Multibody Dynamics: Bridging for Multidisciplinary Applications, in Mechanics of the 21st Century, 2005. Crossref
-
Das Ranjan, Application of Simulated Annealing for Inverse Analysis of a Single-Glazed Solar Collector, in Advances in Intelligent Informatics, 320, 2015. Crossref
-
PARLAK Mehmet, UZMAY İbrahim, DİRSEK FLEKSİYON HAREKETİNDE KASLARIN MOMENT TAŞIMA KARAKTERİSTİKLERİNİN İNCELENMESİ, Konya Journal of Engineering Sciences, 7, 2019. Crossref
-
Campanini Isabella, Disselhorst-Klug Catherine, Rymer William Z., Merletti Roberto, Surface EMG in Clinical Assessment and Neurorehabilitation: Barriers Limiting Its Use, Frontiers in Neurology, 11, 2020. Crossref
-
Baltzopoulos Vasilios, Inverse dynamics, joint reaction forces and loading in the musculoskeletal system: guidelines for correct mechanical terms and recommendations for accurate reporting of results, Sports Biomechanics, 2021. Crossref
-
Saito Tsuyoshi, Ogihara Naomichi, Takei Tomohiko, Seki Kazuhiko, Musculoskeletal Modeling and Inverse Dynamic Analysis of Precision Grip in the Japanese Macaque, Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience, 15, 2021. Crossref
-
Eschweiler Jörg, Praster Maximilian, Quack Valentin, Li Jianzhang, Rath Björn, Hildebrand Frank, Migliorini Filippo, Comparison of Optimization Strategies for Musculoskeletal Modeling of the Wrist for Therapy Planning in Case of Total Wrist Arthroplasty, Life, 12, 4, 2022. Crossref
-
Figueredo Luis F. C., Aguiar Rafael De Castro, Chen Lipeng, Richards Thomas C., Chakrabarty Samit, Dogar Mehmet, Planning to Minimize the Human Muscular Effort during Forceful Human-Robot Collaboration, ACM Transactions on Human-Robot Interaction, 11, 1, 2022. Crossref
-
Herrmann Sven, Kaehler Michael, Souffrant Robert, Rachholz Roman, Zierath János, Kluess Daniel, Mittelmeier Wolfram, Woernle Christoph, Bader Rainer, HiL simulation in biomechanics: A new approach for testing total joint replacements, Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine, 105, 2, 2012. Crossref
-
Zonnino Andrea, Sergi Fabrizio, Model-Based Estimation of Individual Muscle Force Based on Measurements of Muscle Activity in Forearm Muscles During Isometric Tasks, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, 67, 1, 2020. Crossref
-
Nobe Ruka, Yajima Hiroyoshi, Takayama Miho, Takakura Nobuari, Characteristics of Surface Electromyograph Activity of Cervical Extensors and Flexors in Nonspecific Neck Pain Patients: A Cross-Sectional Study, Medicina, 58, 12, 2022. Crossref