Abo Bibliothek: Guest
Journal of Long-Term Effects of Medical Implants

Erscheint 4 Ausgaben pro Jahr

ISSN Druckformat: 1050-6934

ISSN Online: 1940-4379

SJR: 0.184 SNIP: 0.485 CiteScore™:: 1.1 H-Index: 39

Indexed in

Abstract of "The Case for the Establishment of a Code of Ethics to Govern the Frivolous Use of Forensic Biomechanical Testimony to Resolve Legal Issues Involving Alleged Work-Related Musculoskeletal Disorders"

Volumen 18, Ausgabe 1, 2008, 54 pages
DOI: 10.1615/JLongTermEffMedImplants.v18.i1.520
Get accessGet access

ABSTRAKT

Our legal system is broken—especially as it applies to the railroad industry, governed by the now-outdated Federal Employers Liability Act of 1908. Nation-wide, frivolous law suits are filed by the thousands on behalf of plaintiffs claiming alleged work disorders (WMSDs), and they are winning these law suits on a regular basis. Moreover, the general public is funding these settlements because defendants simply pass the costs and losses along to their clients. Much of the reason for plaintiffs' victories in the courtroom can be attributed to unethical “junk science.” Expert witnesses are knowingly and unethically giving false testimony on issues related to medical causation, and juries are being influenced by such testimony because of misleading presumptions of guilt, unless innocence can be proven. In turn, these presumptions are derived from rather convincing “default settings” that are not challenged effectively, either in depositions or at trial. Contributing to this dilemma is the conspicuous absence of a code of ethics to govern the frivolous use of forensic biomechanical testimony to resolve legal issues involving alleged WMSDs. Despite the impact of Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, which was supposed to alleviate these concerns, there is no policy in place to effectively govern the admission and use of scientific evidence—especially biomedical/biomechanical evidence—in settling disputes involving WMSDs. Experts are not being held to strict scientific standards; judges and juries tend naturally to “lean” in favor of plaintiffs (the “David-and-Goliath” syndrome); and the scientific community, through its professional organizations, is not doing a good job of policing the legal community in order to force it to disallow unsubstantiated conjecture and illegitimate fact-based opinions. No doubt some of these law suits are indeed legitimate, and the verdicts are justified and proper. But to deal with those that are not, this paper makes the case for why a code of ethics governing litigation-based biomechanical testimony is long overdue. Discussed are the following: the differences between medical differential diagnosis with presumed cause, and hard scientific evidence proving actual cause; using non sequiturs (including circular reasoning) to arrive at conclusions that do not follow directly from the reasoning that leads up to them; unsubstantiated allegations based on pure conjecture (including bias and the skewed use of biostatistics); several deceptive, misinformed, and misguided “default settings” that are routinely considered to be axiomatic and lead to self-fulling prophecies; a flagrant disregard and abuse of scientific logic and critical thinking (including pitfalls that derive from the famous adages, se non e vero, e ben trovato, circulus in probando, post hoc ergo propter hoc; and petition principii; contradictory observations, wherein precisely opposite outcomes can seemingly be reconciled by the same prevailing theory of causation; failure to account for confounding variables; the “guilty-unless-proven-innocent” syndrome (including proving negatives); the difference between “correlation” and “causation” (as it concerns epidemiological evidence); the difference between “discomfort” and “disease” (as it concerns ergonomic evidence); the straw-that-broke-the-camel's-back argument; and the “DQ(define and quantify) principle” in science.

Zukünftige Artikel

Transfer of guided emergence profile developed using customized provisional implant restoration and cementation using an abutment replica technique- A case report. Vinay Sivaswamy, Balaji Anand S D, Jacob Mathew Philip, C J Venkatakrishnan, Narasimman M, Helen Mary Abraham, Pavithra B Marijuana use is Associated with Increased Rates of Hip Dislocation and Lower Insurance Reimbursement among THA Recipients Andrew Recker, Chukwuweike Gwam, Erin Kelly, Scott Douglas, Johannes Plate Surface modification of Mg alloy AZ91D using nanopowder mixed EDM for Biodegradable Implant Alok Kumar, Abhishek Singh The history of orthopedics in the long term: from general medicine to medical specialties Pavlos Altsitzioglou, Ioannis Zafeiris, Fotini Soucacos, Pantelis Limneos, Eleftheria Souliotis, Evanthia Mitsiokapa, Theodosis Saranteas, Andreas Mavrogenis COMPARISON OF ROUGHNESS, WETTABILITY AND SCANNING ELECTRON MICROSCOPY FEATURES BETWEEN SANDBLASTED ACID-ETCHED AND OXIDIZED TITANIUM DENTAL IMPLANTS Kshitiz Chhabra, Arvina Rajasekar CORRELATION BETWEEN PRIMARY STABILITY OF DENTAL IMPLANTS AND BONE DENSITY: A RETROSPECTIVE ANALYSIS Padmaja S, Arvina Rajasekar C-Reactive Protein and Erythrocyte Sedimentation Rates after total and unicompartmental knee arthroplasty - less implant equals quicker normalization Kasım Kılıçarslan, Ömer Faruk Naldöven, Enejd Veizi, Şahan Güven, Şahin Çepni, Ahmet Fırat COMPLICATIONS FOLLOWING SHORT FEMORAL NAIL FIXATION FOR INTETROCHANTERIC HIP FRACTURES. A RETROSPECTIVE STUDY Anastasia Vasilopoulou, Antonios Trichonas, Konstantinos Palaiologos, Emmanouel Antonogiannakis, Christos Nikakis, Stavros Angelis, Spyridon Maris, Christos Grekas , Efthimios Karadimas, Alexandros Apostolopoulos FEA: Connector Designs and Pontic Stress Distribution of Fixed Partial Denture Implant-Supported Metal Framework Saja Muhsin, Enas Mohammed, Khalid Bander Design and Frequency Stability Analysis of an Adaptive Neuro-Fuzzy Inference System based Artificial Pacemaker Controller in MATLAB Nader Jafarnia Dabanloo, Asghar Dabiriaghdam, Fereidoon Nooshirvan Rahatabad, Keivan Maghooli Complications following intraosseous injections of calcium phosphate bone cement in Subchondroplasty. Christos Zachariadis, Helen Leligou, Stauros Kourkoulis, Evaggelos Magnisalis, Panayiotis Papagelopoulos, Olga Savvidou The Impact of Patient Characteristics on Outcomes of Surgically Managed Vertebral Osteomyelitis in the United States: Insights from a National Database Study Jennifer Kurowicki, Stuart Changoor, Daniel Coban, Neil Patel, Kumar Sinha, Ki Hwang, Arash Emami ASSOCIATION OF AGE, GENDER AND SITE OF IMPLANT PLACEMENT - AN INSTITUTION BASED RETROSPECTIVE STUDY Harini Sri, Nabeel Ahmed, Keerthi Shasanka
Digitales Portal Digitale Bibliothek eBooks Zeitschriften Referenzen und Berichte Forschungssammlungen Preise und Aborichtlinien Begell House Kontakt Language English 中文 Русский Português German French Spain